Open Shelving vs. Closed Cabinets: Which Kitchen Storage Style Fits You Best?

The kitchen isn't just where meals are made — it's where life happens. One of the most debated choices when planning or remodeling a kitchen is this: open shelving vs. closed cabinets.

Do you go for sleek, modern shelves that showcase your best dishes — or stick with tried-and-true cabinets that keep everything neatly tucked away? Your decision impacts not only your kitchen's look and feel but also its daily functionality and maintenance.

In this post, we'll break down the pros, cons, and design insights of open shelving vs. closed cabinets, with expert guidance to help you choose what works best for your lifestyle. Whether you're a minimalist, a busy parent, or someone looking to boost your home's resale value, this guide will help you make an informed decision.

What Are Open Shelves and Closed Cabinets?

Before diving into pros, cons, and design strategies, it's important to define what we’re comparing.

Open Shelving

Open shelving refers to wall-mounted or floating shelves without doors or enclosures. Typically made of wood, metal, or glass, they offer an accessible, minimalist look and are often used to display dishes, plants, cookbooks, or decorative items. You’ll see them featured in modern, farmhouse, Scandinavian, and even industrial kitchen styles.

Design tip: Open shelving works best when kept tidy — what you see is what you get.

Closed Cabinets

Closed cabinets are traditional storage units with doors that conceal their contents. They come in a variety of styles — from shaker to slab to glass-front — and can be fully customized to fit your kitchen layout and storage needs.

Design tip: Closed cabinets provide more design flexibility and hide clutter, making them great for busy or high-traffic kitchens.

Summary Table:  Open Shelves vs Closed Cabinets Common Uses

Also Read: 35+ Coastal Kitchen Ideas That Bring the Beach to Your Home

Aesthetic Appeal: Style Showdown

When it comes to kitchen design, first impressions matter — and your choice between open shelving and closed cabinets plays a huge role in the visual impact of your space.

Open Shelving: Airy & On-Trend

Open shelves have surged in popularity thanks to their modern, minimalist charm. They make kitchens feel larger and more open by eliminating bulky upper cabinetry. This style creates space for curated displays — think ceramic dishware, spice jars, or hanging plants.

But be warned: Open shelves demand discipline. Mismatched mugs or cluttered jars can throw off the entire look. If you're not a natural organizer, this style might be more work than it's worth.

Closed Cabinets: Timeless & Tidy

Closed cabinets offer a polished, streamlined look. They're the go-to for those who prefer a clean, uniform kitchen without visual distractions. Available in countless finishes, they can suit anything from rustic to ultra-modern designs.

While some might see them as traditional, modern cabinetry innovations (like flat-front, push-to-open designs) have kept them fresh and relevant in contemporary kitchens.

Also Read: 27 Stunning Bathroom Tile Ideas to Transform Your Space in 2025

Functionality & Everyday Use

While aesthetics matter, your kitchen’s true test is how well it supports your daily life. That’s where functionality comes into play — and here’s where open shelving and closed cabinets can feel worlds apart.

Open Shelving: Easy Access, But High Maintenance

Open shelves shine when it comes to quick access. No more fumbling with doors — everything is in plain sight and within reach. That’s a win for fast-paced cooks or frequent entertainers.

Functional advantages:

• Grab-and-go convenience
• Encourages organization and decluttering
• Perfect for frequently used items (e.g., plates, spices, glasses)

Drawbacks:

• Not ideal for storing mismatched items or bulky appliances
• Constant exposure to dust, grease, and splatter
• Needs frequent rearranging to stay visually appealing

Closed Cabinets: Storage You Don’t Have to Think About

Closed cabinets offer maximum versatility for storing everything from pots and pans to snack boxes and cleaning supplies — no styling required.

Functional advantages:

• Hides everyday chaos
• Great for heavy-duty storage
• Can be customized with pull-out trays, lazy Susans, dividers, etc.

Drawbacks:

• Can make a kitchen feel more enclosed, especially in small spaces
• Extra steps (opening/closing) might feel inefficient to some

Real-Life Example:

If you cook daily and rely on a wide range of tools — blenders, Instant Pots, baking pans — closed cabinets likely offer the best long-term practicality. But if you're more of a light cooker or love styling your space, open shelves could work well for you.

Also Read: 40+ Bathroom Lighting Ideas: Expert Guide for Stylish & Functional Bathroom Illumination

Maintenance & Cleaning: The Hidden Cost

Source: Photo by molenira

One of the most overlooked factors in choosing between open shelving and closed cabinets is how much time and effort it takes to keep them clean. Spoiler alert: one is a lot more demanding than the other.

Open Shelving: High Style, High Maintenance

Open shelves look beautiful in photos — but what you don’t always see is the dust, grease, and grime that naturally collect in a kitchen.

Cleaning considerations:

• Dishes and decor on open shelves are constantly exposed to airborne grease and food particles
• Regular dusting is a must — at least once a week to prevent buildup
• Requires cleaning both the shelf and every item on it

Closed Cabinets: Low Maintenance, More Forgiving

Closed cabinets offer a layer of protection for your items and are much more forgiving when it comes to mess and dust.

Cleaning considerations:

• Only exterior cabinet surfaces need frequent wiping (typically doors and handles)
• Interiors stay cleaner longer
• Grease and cooking residue are easier to contain

Also Read: 25 Scandinavian Kitchen Design Guide 2025: Inspiration, Layouts & Styling Tips

Storage Capacity & Practicality

Source: Photo by brizmaker

When designing a kitchen, storage is king. No matter how beautiful your space is, if you’re constantly struggling to find room for pots, pans, or pantry staples, it’s not going to work. So how do open shelving and closed cabinets compare when it comes to pure practicality?

Open Shelving: Stylish, But Limited

Open shelves are ideal for displaying, not hiding. While they can hold everyday items, their strength lies in showcasing — not maximizing — space.

Storage Pros:

• Keeps essentials like mugs or plates within reach
• Creates a feeling of openness, especially in small kitchens
• Great for minimalists with limited kitchenware

Storage Cons:

• Can’t handle heavy or bulky items
• No hidden storage for odds and ends
• Limited vertical stacking compared to enclosed cabinetry

If you live with kids, roommates, or just own a lot of stuff, open shelves alone may not be enough.

Closed Cabinets: Workhorses of the Kitchen

Closed cabinets are designed for maximum efficiency. From base cabinets that store heavy appliances to overhead cabinets that reach the ceiling, this system provides deep, customizable storage for kitchens of all sizes.

Storage Pros:

• Deeper and more secure storage
• Custom insert options (pull-out trays, spice racks, appliance lifts)
• Utilizes vertical space more efficiently

Storage Cons:

• May require bending or stretching to access deep cabinets
• Harder to visually organize unless you use clear containers or labels

Also Read: How to Create a Hamptons Style Bathroom in Australia: Coastal Elegance Meets Everyday Luxury

Cost Comparison: Budget Breakdown

Budget is often a decisive factor in any kitchen remodel or design update. Understanding the financial impact of open shelving vs. closed cabinets will help you plan realistically.

Open Shelving: Affordable & DIY-Friendly

Open shelves generally come with a lower price tag due to fewer materials and simpler installation.

Cost factors:

• Materials: Wood planks, metal brackets, or pre-made shelves can be inexpensive
• Installation: Often DIY-friendly, saving on labor costs
• Customization: Limited, so fewer costly custom options

Average cost estimate: The average cost of open shelving in Australia typically ranges from AUD $100 to $500 per linear metre, depending on factors such as materials, design complexity, and installation requirements.

Closed Cabinets: Higher Initial Investment, Long-Term Value

Closed cabinets require more materials, hardware (hinges, handles), and professional installation. However, they can add significant value to your home and last for decades.

Cost factors:

• Materials: Wood, MDF, laminate, or custom hardwoods vary widely
• Labor: Skilled carpentry or cabinet makers needed
• Extras: Soft-close hinges, pull-outs, lighting add to the price

Average cost estimate: The average cost of closed cabinetry in Australia typically ranges from AUD $500 to $4,000+ per linear metre (equivalent to $150–$1,200+ per linear foot), depending on factors like cabinetry quality, materials, level of customization, and design complexity.

Return on Investment (ROI)

According to real estate experts, well-designed closed cabinets typically offer better resale value by appealing to a broader buyer base. Open shelving, while trendy, may date faster or deter buyers looking for traditional storage.

Budget Tip: Consider a hybrid approach — combining open shelving for display with closed cabinets for bulk storage — to balance cost and style.

Also Read: 25+ Ways to Save Water: Practical Tips for Your Kitchen, Bathroom, Laundy Room, and Garden!

Hybrid Option: Best of Both Worlds?

Source: Photo by ArchiViz

What if you didn’t have to choose just open shelving or only closed cabinets? Many modern kitchens embrace a hybrid approach, blending both storage types for a perfect balance of style and function.

Why Choose a Hybrid?

• Display & Conceal: Open shelves showcase your favorite items — think colorful dishes, cookbooks, or heirloom pottery — while closed cabinets hide less attractive essentials like Tupperware, cleaning supplies, or bulky appliances.
• Visual Interest: Mixing open and closed units breaks monotony and adds depth to your kitchen design.
• Functional Zones: Open shelves near prep areas for frequently used items; closed cabinets near the floor or in less accessible spots.

Also Read: How to Confidently Mix Kitchen Knobs, Pulls & Fixtures for a Custom Look

So Which One Is Right for You?

Choosing between open shelving vs. closed cabinets ultimately boils down to your unique lifestyle, priorities, and kitchen habits. Below is a quick decision flowchat to help you choose:

Quick Decision Flowchart (Simplified)

• Want easy maintenance & maximum storage → Closed Cabinets
• Love displaying decor & don’t mind upkeep → Open Shelving
• Want a mix of both → Hybrid Approach

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Your kitchen is a reflection of your life — choose the storage solution that fits you best!

Matching Your Cabinets With Nero Tapware’s Aesthetic Collections

When you're designing your dream kitchen, choosing between open shelving and closed cabinets is just one piece of the puzzle. To really pull everything together, the right fittings and finishes can make all the difference. That’s where Nero Tapware’s aesthetic collections come in. Whether you're leaning toward the sleek, modern vibe of open shelving or the more classic look of closed cabinetry, Nero’s range offers the perfect complement.

Think about finishes like matte black, brushed gold, chrome and more— these timeless yet contemporary options will seamlessly integrate with your cabinetry, enhancing both the style and functionality of your space. We offer various collections to suit the unique needs of different customers like Caravan, Vibe, Classic, Pearl, X Plus, and others.

By choosing Nero Tapware alongside your cabinetry, you're not just adding fixtures, you're transforming your kitchen into a space that’s both highly functional and stunningly stylish. Need help? Contact us now!

Also Read: The Ultimate Outdoor Kitchen Guide for Australians: DIY Tips, Designs, and Ideas